So... the first batch was awesome and looked like Greek yogurt. It was fresh and amazing, elevated every meal.

The second week, it arrived grainy and tasting like cottage cheese and sour cream had a baby. It was partially liquified. It still smelled fresh (aka not spoilt), but I don't feel comfortable eating this based on the texture.

One ingredient: Grade A pasteurized cultured cream. Having never been a sour cream fan, I am delighted that I love this stuff. Raises both pierogis and stroganoff to new heights.

I love this sour cream because it's real sour cream without a bunch of other ingredients. Can't beat it!

I can’t go back to Tillamook after using this. We bought a tub on a whim once and it was all I could talk about for 6 months until I could get more. Delicious straight off the spoon!

My Hungarian husband said he finally found a sour cream that tasted like home with Smith Bros’ sour cream. I’ve heard him complain about sour cream quality for years. Thank you for solving this long-standing problem! We order multiple pounds at a time- so good.

I don't normally gush over dairy products, but I've just tried this and it's like what my great grandmother used to make--creamy, not too sharp, works well in eastern european cooking. Sorry it took me so long to try it!

I'm not sure what other reviewers are referring to when they say it has too many odd ingredients - the only ingredient is cultured cream. Maybe they used to have a different recipe?
In any case, this sour cream is delicious, thick and so smooth. If you like Daisy sour cream, this is just as good if not better. My 5 year old daughter asks to lick the serving spoon at the end of the meal.

This is not liquid slop you get from the store. Makes great onion dip, bake potatoes cover, tacos. The list goes on and on.

My husband refuses to buy any other sour cream.  He says this is the best he has ever had yet.

Previous containers were very good, last week the container foil was bulging and the contents were watery.  It tasted metallic, the date was fine, but we threw it out.

Seriously, buy this. It's the only kind our family will eat.

Only sour cream we buy.

The taste is great, the consistency is smooth and creamy. I think is the best I've ever tried!!

This is the best sour cream ever!  The taste is amazing and it's so smooth and creamy. yum!

I usually buy Tillamook sour cream but due to timing I took advantage of the product Smith Brothers delivers.  When I finally tried the Smith Brothers Farms sour cream I was extremely disappointed.  Not only do the ingredients list have a bunch of ridiculous additives- the flavor is horrible. The consistency was off, the flavor was odd (not spoiled off, but just yuck) and YES the date was good. I will try to find a recipe that will use the rest of the tub. But I won't be purchasing this Smith Brothers Farm branded product again. The sour cream is a no go. Back to Tillamook brand. Very disappointing.

Would love to add sour cream to my regular delivery but I am put off by the extensive ingredient list when I know others can do without. Please consider revising your recipe!

Best sour cream around

Ingredient deck is rather bad.   Consistency is also a little questionable.   Add the fact that the plant that made it is not even disclosed definitely makes this something to avoid.  Frankly this product is a distance from the farm - the ingredient deck alone approaches its being a processed food.

Hands down the best sour cream! And I use a lot of it. It's so good that my friend who doesn't have Smith Brothers makes me order it for her when she needs sour cream! Rich and creamy. Tastes fresh.

This is the only sour cream we buy! It’s so thick and creamy! Absolutely love it!

The best sour cream ever!!!!

I tried this sour cream for the first time a couple weeks ago and it had a great flavor.  Growing up in Maine, my aunt had a dairy farm and this sour cream had a similar flavor to fresh churned butter. Wonderful!