Normally I am not a big fan of strawberry rhubarb pie, but this pie exceeded all my expectations from the filling to the crust. I will definitely get this again. Worth every penny!

crust was soggy and it was fairly flat tasting

so delicious! everything about it was perfect!

This was really a wonderful pie, tart-sweet with a crumbly, tender crust. Loved it!

I was really hoping that this pie would be worth the money. It definitely was not. The crust was soggy and not flaky at all. I won’t be buying this pie again.

mediocre.  

The pie I received from Smith Brothers Farms was as wonderful as the pie I had at the Whidbey Pie cafe 12 years ago. Light delicate crust and slightly sweet yet tasty filling. (I heated it up)
Considering rising prices and having to take a ferry from Whidbey Island, I find the price reasonable. I have paid $20 for the same hand crafted whole Whidbey pie from Metropolitan Market for the past few years.

If you are a late night sweets eater and on a diet, this pie is for you! There is no way to stealthfully crack open this pie in the middle of the night without waking the entire household.

On another note, if you like a straight rhubarb pie, like myself, you will be delighted with this pie. There is still a tart rhubarb taste accompanied with a slight sweetness. The crust is great as well. All around good pie, however $19 for a standard store bought pie size (not costco size) is steep. Because of this (and because I can't indulge in my shameful midnight snacking in peace lol) I will not put this on my standing order, but will only order once in awhile.